Physician’s Choice vs Garden of Life – Which Probiotic for Women is Better?

Physician’s Choice vs Garden of Life – Which Probiotic for Women is Better?

Garden of Life vs Physician's Choice

Hi there, its James Foster again.

My focus today is to compare two notable brands in this space: Garden of Life and Physician’s Choice. These brands have significantly influenced the health supplement market with their unique approaches, product ranges, and brand philosophies.

Through this comparison, I aim to provide insights into each brand’s specifics, assisting women in making an informed decision for their probiotic needs.

Only by understanding the differences between these two, consumers can decide on which one of these serves their needs the best, their products to be precise.

Garden of Life Probiotics

Garden of Life Probiotics

Founded in 2000 by Jordan Rubin, Garden of Life has established itself as a trusted name in the health supplement industry.

The brand offers an extensive range of nutrition products, including a variety of probiotics for women, vitamins, herbal blends, protein powders, and collagen products.

What sets Garden of Life apart is its commitment to catering to diverse dietary needs, offering vegan, paleo, keto, and gluten-free options.

Garden of Life’s dedication to quality and safety is evident in its products, which are frequently recommended by healthcare professionals.

The brand’s transparency in its manufacturing process and its commitment to environmental sustainability have earned it a B Corporation certification and the distinction of being the first supplement company to achieve carbon-neutral certification.

The brand’s products are available both in physical retail stores and online, making them easily accessible. Prices vary, reflecting the quality and specific formulation of each product.

Garden of Life also offers a generous return policy for customers who are not satisfied with their purchases. Positive customer reviews often highlight the brand’s effectiveness and commitment to transparency.

Physician’s Choice Probiotics

Physician's Choice Probiotics

Physician’s Choice, an e-commerce store specializing in health supplements, has rapidly gained popularity since its inception in 2017 by founders Logan Chierotti and Ryan Russo.

The brand focuses on using pure, standardized, science-backed ingredients, ensuring that each product, including their probiotics for women, is potent and safe.

The company’s approach to supplements centers around high-quality, single-hero ingredients, sourced from reputable suppliers and manufactured in the United States.

This focus is reflected in their diverse product range, which includes Ashwagandha, probiotics, collagen peptides, and more, catering to various health needs.

Physician’s Choice has garnered positive customer feedback, particularly for the effectiveness of their products and their excellent customer service.

The brand offers attractive discounts, such as 30% off on collagen products and a 15% discount for newsletter subscribers, making their products more accessible.

Available for purchase on their website, Amazon, and Walmart, Physician’s Choice also provides a 30-day return policy and free standard shipping, enhancing customer satisfaction and trust.


When comparing Garden of Life and Physician’s Choice, several factors stand out.

Product Range and Ingredients

Ingredients and product range are among the most important elements to consider.

Garden of Life

Garden of Life offers a wide array of probiotic products, each tailored to different health needs and preferences. This variety ensures that consumers have multiple options to choose from, depending on their specific health requirements.

 Raw Daily Probiotics for Women Ultimate Care 

One of their notable products, it contains 34 probiotic strains and a high count of 100 billion CFUs. This diversity in strains and high CFU count are indicative of a broad-spectrum approach to gut health.

 Quality and Dietary Considerations 

This product is raw, gluten-free, vegetarian-friendly, and free from added fillers or soy allergens. These attributes make it suitable for individuals with specific dietary preferences or sensitivities.

Physician’s Choice

Physician's Choice 60 Billion Probiotic Product Overview

Physician’s Choice, while having a narrower range compared to Garden of Life, focuses on delivering targeted probiotic formulas. This approach caters to consumers seeking specific probiotic blends.

 60 Billion CFUs with Diverse Strains 

Their prominent probiotic supplement contains 60 billion CFUs with 10 different strains, including six Lactobacillus strains and four Bifidobacterium strains. This blend aims to provide a balanced probiotic profile for gut health.

 Inclusion of Prebiotic Blend 

A distinctive feature of their product is the inclusion of a prebiotic blend with ingredients like artichoke root and chicory root. Prebiotics are essential for nourishing the probiotics for women and enhancing their efficacy in the gut.

 Allergen-Free and Dietary Compliance 

Similar to Garden of Life, Physician’s Choice probiotics for women are dairy-free and devoid of common allergens like binders, soy, and gluten. This makes their products accessible to individuals with various dietary restrictions.

Quality and Effectiveness

When it comes to quality and effectiveness, the situation should be understood precisely, by taking a look at the smallest of details.

Garden of Life
Feature Description
Strain Diversity Offers a wide variety of probiotic strains, catering to different health needs and preferences.
CFU Count Products have a substantial Colony Forming Units (CFU) count, indicating a high number of probiotic bacteria.
Overall Effectiveness Known for supporting gut health and immune functions effectively, as reflected in customer reviews and expert opinions.
Additional Notes Emphasis on environmental sustainability and a broad range of health supplements.

Physician’s Choice
Feature Description
High CFU Count Known for its products having 60 billion CFUs, a very high amount of probiotic bacteria.
Prebiotic Blend Includes a blend of prebiotics to feed and support the probiotics, aiding their survival in the gut.
User Experiences While many users report positive effects on digestion, some experience temporary side effects like bloating and upset stomach.
Additional Notes Focuses on high CFU counts, and affordable pricing, and is often recommended for budget-conscious consumers.


Physician's Choice vs Garden of Life Pricing

The pricing strategy of Garden of Life and Physician’s Choice reflects their distinct brand philosophies and market positions:

Garden of Life Pricing

Garden of Life’s products are typically priced higher, which can be attributed to their wide range of offerings. They provide a diverse array of probiotic supplements, each tailored to different health needs and preferences.

The higher price point also reflects the brand’s commitment to environmental sustainability in the market.

Garden of Life has made significant efforts to ensure its products are eco-friendly, which often involves additional costs in sourcing and manufacturing. This pricing strategy is consistent with its positioning as a premium brand in the health supplement market, targeting consumers who are willing to pay extra for organic, sustainable, and diverse product options.

Physician’s Choice Pricing

A 30-serving bottle of Physician’s Choice Probiotics is priced at $27.95. This pricing is relatively affordable compared to many competitors in the probiotic supplement market, including Garden of Life.

Physician’s Choice offers discounts for subscriptions, making it an even more budget-friendly option for regular users. This pricing strategy aligns with their brand image of providing high-quality supplements at accessible prices.

The competitive pricing of Physician’s Choice is particularly appealing to consumers who prioritize affordability but still seek a high-quality probiotic supplement.

Their focus is on high CFU counts and targeted strains, like Lactobacillus Gasseri, Acidophilus, Plantarum, Paracasei, Casei, and Bifidobacterium Lactis. Combined with an affordable price point, positions them as a value-for-money brand in the supplement market.


Does it matter which probiotic I use?

Different probiotics for women contain different strains and CFU counts, which can target various aspects of gut health. It’s important to choose a probiotic based on your specific health needs and any dietary restrictions.

What is the best gut supplement?

The best gut supplement varies depending on individual health needs. Factors like CFU count, strain diversity, and the presence of prebiotics can influence effectiveness. It’s advisable to consult a healthcare professional to determine the best option for your specific requirements.

Do doctors recommend probiotics?

Many doctors recommend probiotics, especially for digestive health issues, as they can help balance the gut microbiome. However, recommendations can vary based on individual health conditions and the specific probiotic product.

Who should not take probiotics?

People with compromised immune systems, those who have had surgery, and individuals with certain critical illnesses should be cautious about taking probiotics. It’s important to consult a healthcare provider before starting any probiotic supplement, especially for those with underlying health conditions.

Closing Thoughts

Both Garden of Life and Physician’s Choice stand as formidable options, each with its unique strengths.

Garden of Life’s extensive product range, environmental commitments, and third-party certifications make it a great choice for those who value sustainability and variety.

Physician’s Choice, with its focus on high-quality ingredients and affordability, is ideal for those seeking targeted and effective health supplements without breaking the bank. Ultimately, the choice between the two brands will depend on individual preferences, dietary needs, and health goals.

Most Recent

Related Posts